3:10 TO YUMA
A MAJOR MOTION PICTURE
Review by Steven
Anderson Law
www.readwest.com
After a week at number
one in the box office, 3:10 TO YUMA has proven one
of two things: either America loves Westerns, or America loves Russell
Crowe. I’d say it’s likely a combination of the two, but for whatever
reason, the two came together nicely.
In the wake of the
disastrous SEPTEMBER DAWN, 3:10 TO YUMA took the reins and showed us all
that good westerns can be made. This action-packed shoot’em up kept up the
pace and entertained us to the end. Critics raved about this film, and
though it may be the best Western since UNFORGIVEN, it is certainly none
to compare. Though both films had their share of drama, 3:10 was more
about the action, more about the myth of the gunfighter, than human
failings.
Kudos goes out to
setting, to costume, to the script, and to casting, but thumbs down to
period authenticity, and in some cases, reality. Though the ability to
shoot handguns in remarkable fashion has entertained us for years, and
through myth made conceivable, the critical eyes of today’s audience
expects more from some of the simple things. There were certain flaws in
this film with weaponry, and also to how someone would function after
being gut shot. But, those things aside, the movie quickly draws us back
to the attractive setting, the action, and the remarkable screen presence
of the cast.
It’s interesting that
3:10 TO YUMA has yet another western to follow, with Brad Pitt hitting the
Western landscape in THE ASSINATION OF JESSE JAMES BY THE COWARD BOB FORD.
That film alone has had Western enthusiasts hopeful that Hollywood will
take notice of how America loves the genre, and will pay to see these
films, especially with someone as bankable as Brad Pitt. There’s been a
lot of hearsay as to how bad the film will flop, but only the opening
weekend (September 21) can tell.
3:10 TO YUMA was a good
Western, but what America, or the world for that matter, is yet to see, is
another GREAT Western. One could measure such success by the box office
history, where by today’s standard, if a movie doesn’t break a $100
million in sales, especially with most budgets over $50 million, it’s just
a mediocre movie.
As for Westerns, it’s
been almost two decades since a Western film has broke $100 million in
sales. In fact, only four westerns, in the history of cinema, have ever
reached that mark. The first, which has a long-time standing at the number
two Western, is BUTCH CASSIDY AND THE SUNDANCE KID, with a gross of $102
million. And that movie was made in 1969.
It was 1994 since a
Western made that mark when MAVERICK, starring Mel Gibson, hit the silver
screen. The remake of a classic character stands at number three on the
all-time list with sales at a little over $101 million. Just a few
thousand short, at the number four spot, is UNFORGIVEN, released in 1992.
It’s no surprise that the number one grossing western of all time is
DANCES WITH WOLVES, with domestic sales at over $184 million, and
internationally at over $424 million. And that movie was made in 1990.
Other Western films have
been made, but none have got close to the $100 million mark. In fact,
number five on the list, HIDALGO, falls way short at $67 million. Some
have made money, some haven’t. Some have had fairly decent star power, but
for some reason or another, it runs out of steam at the box office.
Looking at the top four
films, it’s no doubt that the key to making a GREAT Western takes star
power. We have Mel Gibson, big in that decade. In 1969 we had Robert
Redford and Paul Newman, huge draws at that time for the mainstream
audience. And Clint Eastwood is a Western icon, who also draws from the
mainstream. Kevin Costner was a big star in 1990, but the real power
behind DANCES WITH WOLVES was the script and the imagery. It was
beautifully drafted and perfectly set, and more precisely, it was
politically correct. It took a twist on the Western and made the good guys
the Indians. It showed us that the mainstream audience was tired of the
superficial macho white guy with a gun. Instead, we had a white
sympathizer who dared to go directly to the scene and discover a people,
not a problem.
3:10 TO YUMA was not an
original idea, and it certainly will not challenge the top films of the
genre. Will Brad Pitt as Jesse James? Hard to say. With the exception of
George Clooney, there is no bigger star than Brad Pitt, so it certainly
has the potential. A lot will depend on the movie itself, and whether or
not it grabs and entertains.
The positive side to
both films is that they can set the pace for more Westerns on the big
screen. And hopefully, if studios take a look at history, and what it took
to make great Westerns, then another original great is right around the
corner. Until then, go see 3:10 TO YUMA. You’ll be glad you did.